Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout _ 9.14(a)--Contract with Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP to Provide Legal Services GI �" Y C� F � � �- ' � ° � � i � CITY OF REDDING �� REPORT TO THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: March 17, 2026 FROM: Christian M. Curtis, City ITEM NO. 9.14(a) Attorney ***APPROVED BY*** ccurtis@cityof'redding.org �'`�� �„:w. u, � i`� a r: �_ •��` Y'��� � ''� � " � u. G�zClial� ar�ax��',�:~� lti��uager ��IT 3(ly3/202� wtarbox@cityofredding.gov SUBJECT: 9.14(a)--Consider approval of Contract with Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP to rovide le al services as Interim Cit Attorne . Recommendation Approve contract with Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP, in a not-to-exceed amount of $300,000, for the provision of legal services as Interim City Attorney for the City of Redding, effective upon signing. Fiscal Impact The total cost of the proposed contract with Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP, is a General Fund expenditure with a fiscal impact of up to three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000.00) to be billed in the amount of$335.00 per hour for Fiscal Years (FY) 2025-26 and 2026-27. Hourly charges for legal services provided will be billed and paid monthly. Billing rates may be subject to periodic review and adjust�nent as agreed in writing between the City of Redding (City) and Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP. Costs wi11 be partially offset by savings, due to the vacancy of City Attorney. The impact to each department is determined by allocating the difference between the contract max ($300,000) and 3 months of personnel savings in FY 2026 and two months of personnel savings in FY 27. This allocation was based on the assumed cross charge rate of the City Attorney to Airports, RABA, R�IA, Redding Electric Utility, Risk/Liability and Employer Services divisions. Alternative Actzons The Council could decline to approve th� proposed contract and give staff alternate direction with regard to seeking negotiations with another firm. Report to Redding City Council March 13,2026 Re: 9.14(a)--Contract with Burke, Williams&Sorensen, LLP to Provide Legal Services Page 2 Background/Analysis City Attorney Curtis has given the City Council notice that he is leaving his position with the City of Redding and has signed a contract with the City of Milpitas. The City has initiated a formal recruitment to fmd a replacement City Attorney, but that process wi11 not be complete before Curtis leaves. As such, skilled City Attorney services will be needed for the interim period. The City Attorney is the legal counsel for the City Council and City staff, advising City officials on all legal matters involving the City. The City Attorney reviews all contracts, leases and agreements entered into by the City, assists departments in the research and development of City resolutions and ordinances, oversees the Risk Management Liability, Litigation and Insurance Division, and represents the City in state and federal court. Most matters addressed by the City Attorney are critical in nature and time sensitive. Burke, Williams & Sorensen, LLP, has an experienced public law practice group that provides city attorney services. The managing partner of their Marin office, Benjamin Stock, has experience as a City Attorney for City of Benicia and Foster City and has tackled a range of challenging municipal law issues, including organizational turn around. The proposed contract would have Mr. Stock serve as the Interim City Attorney, although a majority of day-to-day work is expected to be handled by another partner in the firm, Mary Wagner. Ms. Wagner also has extensive municipal law experience, including twenty years as the City Attorney for the City of Sausalito. It is recommended that the Council approve the proposed contract with Burke, Williams & Sorensen and appoint Mr. Stock as Interim City Attorney effective as of April 5, 2026. This timing will allow a short period of overlap, during which utilization of outside counsel is expected to be limited and focused on ensuring a smooth hand-off. The City Manager and outgoing City Attorney will work with departments during this period to establish processes and expectations for the utilization of outside counsel until the recruitment for a full-time city attorney is complete. Environmental Review This is not a project de�ned under the California Environmental quality Act, and no further action is required. Council Priorities/City Manager Goals This agenda item is a routine operational item. Attachments Budget Resolution Agreement for Professional Services - Burke, Williams & Sorensen Resolution No. 2026 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF REDDING APPROVING AND ADOPTiNG THE 30Tx AMENDMENT TO CITY BUDGET RESOLUTION NO. 2025-049 APPROPRIATING $177,170 FOR THE CONTRACT WITH BURKE, WILLIAMS & SORENSON, LLP FOR THE PROVISION OF LEGAL SERVICES AS INTERIM CITY ATTORNEY FOR FISCAL YEAR 2025-26. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF REDDING THAT Budget Resolution No. 2025-049 be and is hereby amended as follows: Fiscal Year 2026 FUND DNISION DESCRIPTION INCREASE DECREASE 101 1031 City Attorney $79,730 196 9103 Redding Area Housing Authority $2,210 201 7101 Redding Regional Airport $2,210 211 8005 Electric Utility $13,290 291 6901 Redding Area Bus Authority $3,320 381 3801 Risk/Liability $62,020 391 3901 Employer Services $14,390 Fiscal Year 2027 FUND DIVISION DESCRIPTION 1NCREASE DECREASE 101 1031 City Attorney $22,300 196 9103 Redding Area Housing Authority $620 201 '7101 Redding Regional Airport $620 211 8005 Electric Utility $3,720 291 6901 Redding Area Bus Authority $930 381 3 801 Risk/Liability $1�,340 391 3901 Employer Services $4,030 THAT account titles and numbers requiring adjustments by this Resolution are as follows: Fiscal Year 2026 USE SOURCE OF FUNDS OF FUNDS Increase(Decrease)Revenue 101-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 79,730 196-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 2,210 201-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 2,210 211-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 13,290 291-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 3,320 381-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 62,020 391-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ 14,390 Increase(Decrease)Expenditures 101-1031-5037501-00000 Professional Services&Consulting $ 79,730 196-9103-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 2,210 201-'7101-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 2,210 211-8005-8923871-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 13,290 291-6901-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 3,320 381-3801-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 62,020 391-3901-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ 14,390 Total $ 177,170 $ 177,170 Fiscal Year 2027 USE SOURCE OF FUNDS OF FUNDS Increase(Decrease)Revenue 101-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (22,300) 196-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (620) 201-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (620) 211-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (3,�20) 291-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (930) 381-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (17,340) 391-0000-2910000-00000 Fund Balance $ (4,030) Increase(Decrease)Expenditures 101-1031-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ (22,300) 196-9103-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ (620) 201-'7101-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ (620) 211-8005-89238'71-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ (3,'720) 291-6901-5037501-00000 Professional Services&Consulting $ (930) 381-3801-5037501-00000 Professional Services& Consulting $ (17,340) 391-3901-5037501-00000 Professional Services&Consulting $ (4,030) Torat � �49,s6o� $ �49,s6o� THAT the purpose is to appropriate $177,170 for a contract with Burke, Williams & Sorenson, LLP for the provision of legal services as Interim City Attorney for Fiscal Year 2025-26. I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing Resolution was introduced at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Redding on the 17th day of March 2026 and was duly adopted at said meeting by the following vote: AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS: NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS: ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS: ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS: MIKE LITTAU, Mayor ATTEST: FORM APPROVAL: SHARLENE TIPTON, City Clerk CHRISTIAN M. CURTIS, City Attorney AGREEMEI�TT FOR PRQFESSI�DNAL SERVICES THIS AGREEMENT is made by and between the City of Redding;Office of the Gity Atttrrney("City")and Burke, Williams & Sorensen, I,LP {"Firm"). City desires to retain$enjamin L. Stock tc� act as Iltterim Gity Attomey. NQW,THEREF032E, Cit�and Firm agree as follows: 1, Periad of Perform�nee; This Agreement shall begin on the contract c�ate and shall cc�ntinue until the City successfully retains a permanent City Attoi-ney. 2. Firm's Services and Responsibilities: Firrri �vi11 act as Interri�m City Attomey and prnvide services to City as described in Attachment °'A"' hereta. Benjamin L. Stock("Partner") will personally serue-as the Interim City Attorney and may utilize other attorneys at the firm as apprapriate. Mr. Stock has been selected and specifically retained to bring his skill, training, legal expertise, and prafessiana�judgment tc�represent and provide ct�unsel to the City. Firm shall provide�ity with the necessary services by staff qualified to perfarm the tasks at the least costly billing category. Firm shall have and maintain all backup documentation to support a11 entries included in its billings. Firm shall provide information to the City's insurance carrier andlor excess insurance c�rrier on an as-needed basis when so directed by the City Council Qr City Manager: 3. Compensatian a. Fees i: The total amount payabie to Firm for the services to be rendered by this Agreement is unknown at this time but shall not exceed Three Hur�dt�d Thousand Dollars ($30t?,�00} without the prior approval of the City and amendment of this Agreement. ii. Firm shall provide legal services at the billing rates listed on Attachrnent "B", attached and incorparated herein. iii. Billing rates rnay be subjec�ta periodic review and adjustment as agreed in writing between City and Firm, Any rate increase shall require a written amendment to t�is Agreement. Agreement for Professianal Services 1 b. Expenses City shall reimburse Firm fc�r its actual out-of-packet expenses but without any additional costs for having aduanced the funds.Fum shall nt�te that City is exernpt from all filing fee charges. i: Reirnbtzrsable ardi�ary expenses shall include,but not be lirnited to: {1) Deposition fees {2} Transcript fe�s (3) F'ostag� (4) Messenger service (5) Pr�cess service (6) Long distance telephone charges (7) L)acurnent reproductit�n by outside vendor {$) Expenses for travel (9) In-house dacument reproductian. I� amount charged in any one month exeeeds $lt7(?.00, the billing statement shall cantain: {a) Purpose far the reproduction, (b} Title of each document reproduced; (c) Nurrrber of pages repraduced; (d) Total number of copies made;and �e} Cost per page. ii. Reimbursable extraardinary expenses shall inc�ude charges for which Firm has obtained City Council or City Manager's pnor approval, �tich expenses shall includ�,but nat be lirnited ta: (1) Consultant(s�fees (2) Expert witr�ess fees (3) Investigative services costs (4) t)ther expenses ap�roved in advance by City Manager iii. Non-reimbursable ex�enses shall include;but not be limited ta: (1) Stafftime dr overtime farperforming secretarial, clerical, or word processing functions {2) Charges for titne spent ta provide necessary information for City audits c�r billing inquiries {3) Charges for�ork perf`orrned which had not been authori�ed by City, such work shall be a gratuitous effort by Firm Agreement for Frofessional Services � 4. Billin�s and P�yments a. Billin�s i. Firm sha11 submit its itemized,billing statement monthly to City Manager no later than the tenth of the month follawing the manth service was rendered. ii. The original billing statement(s) s17all be submittetl to: +City Manager City of Redciing 777 Cypress Avenue Redding,CA 960fl l iii. Each billing statement shall be iternized in a time reporting format acceptable to Gity and shall include a�i�inal invQices for reimbursement of expenses, Firm shall not be reimbursed for expenses unless the c�riginal invoice is submitted. iv. Firm shall have and maintain all backup documentation to support all entries included in the monthly billing statement. Such dacumentatit��shall be in a form subject to audit and in accordanc� with generally accepted ac�ounting principles. Fu-m shall rnalce st�ch dacurnentatian available to auditors upon request. b. Payrnents i. City's legal and accounting staff shall review all billing statements in accardance with its review prc�cedures: ii. City sha11 rnake its best effort ta process payments prarnptly after receiving Fiu-m's monthly t�'rlting statement. City shalt nt�t pay interest c�r frnance charges on any outstanding balance(s). 5. Insurance a. Firm shall obtain and maintain in full force and effect a prafessional liability insurance policy which prc�vides coverage rn an amount ofnat Iess than one million dollars {$1,0�0,000) per occurrence and two millian dollars ($2,000;000) aggregate. Firm agrees ta provide City with a Certificate of Ins�:trance evidencing said prafessianal liability insurance policy. Said insurance policy shall provide coverage to the City far any damages or losses suffered by the City as a result of any error or amission c�r neglect by Firm, or any Firms or paralegals emplgyed or associated by Firm vvhich arises out c�f the professional services required by this Agreement. Such insurance may be subject to a self-insur�d retention or deductiible to be borne entirely by Firn�. Agreement for Professioaal Services 3 b, Fu�m shall obtain and maintain warkers'compensatian insurance in accordance with secti�n 3700 of the Calif�rnia Labor Cc�de. Firm agrees to provide City with a Certificate of Insuranee evidencing said workers'compensation insurance policy. c. Fum agrees to notify the City within ten (10) calendar days in the event the lirnits of�'irm's insurance should fall belc�w the coveiage stated in this Secti�an,ar if the insurance policies noted here are allowed to lapse and substitute insurance is not abtained. 6. Lifi�atian, Lleposiiion, and Other Testimony: If Firm is ask�d or required ta prepare foranc�lor testify,including, without limitatic�n, at deposition, trial, arbitration or any ot�er proceeding,because of services rendered under this Agreement ar if Firm must respond t� subpoenas crr discc�very or othenvise respond or perform services with respect to any matter relating to or arising out c�f the services perf`c�rmed for City,the City agrees to pay Firm a rate of$32S pen c��ur for all time e�cpended(including preparation tirne} and to xeimburse Firm for reasanable costs and expenses incurred, whether or not the investigation has been concluded at the rates set forth herein: This includes reasonable costs of 1ega1 representation, The City shall either represent tlle Fi�tmm when it testifies or select and provide an atte�rney to repr�sent the �irrn, Furthertnore, the City shall be procedurally and financi�lly responsible for addressing and resp�nding ta any subpoena, disc�very request, and/c�r action af any kind, including a rnotion to compel �rodtzction of Firm's file(s} �nd any fee and/or cost attendant theieta If the City e�pects the Frrm to ol��ect to a subpoena for investigation file(s) and/c�r the Firm's testimony, the City will compensate the�irtn f�r all attorney's fees incurred in responding to the subpoena and/or mation to compel prociuction. 7. Termination; This Agreement may irnmediately be terminated without cause in whole or in part at any time either party, in its sale discretion, deems to be in its best interest. Services may be terminated by delivering a �vritten Terminatian Notice specifying the extent to which services are terminated and the effective termination date. 8. T�rmination Due to Conflict of Ynterest: If either Firm c�r Gity determines a matter of professional conflict has arisen which should not or could not be postpc�ned until the canclusion of the matter,Firm pr City rnay give written notic� c�f imrnediat� ternzinati�n af this Agreement subject ta Firrn's duty to provide adequate �epresentation until the appropriate substitutions can be made. 9. Notices; All notices and required repc�rts shall be written and hand delivered or mailed by first class, pt�stage prepaitl, addressed to City or Firm at the addresses belaw; or at any other�ddress City or Firm shall pravide in writing tt� each other. a, rf to City: Uffice af the City Manager 777 Cypress Avenue, 3ra Floar Redding, CA 960�1 Agceement,for Professional Services 4 Copies af reports,but nat notices or bills, shall also be sent to: City Clerlc '777 Cypress Avenue, 3rd Floor Redding,CA 960fl1 b. If to Fum: Burke, Williams &Sorensen, LLP 181 Third Street, Ste. 200 San Rafael,California 94901-658'7 10� Assi�;nment a. No part af this Agreement or any right or obligation arising frarn it is assignable withotit City's written consent. b. However,Firm may retain consultants and experts as Firrn deems apprapriate after recei�ing City's writt�n appraval, 11. Standarci Terms a�nd Candrti�ns a. Indemnification Firm shall indemnify, defend, and save han�nless City, its agents, c�fficers, and employees from and against any and all liability expense, incl�iding defense costs and legal fees, and claims for damages resulting from Finm`s wiliful misconduct ar c�rnissions or negligent act or any bodily injury, death,personal injury, ar p�roperty damage (including Firm's propertY), in connection: with F'urn's' operations or its services, including any workers' compensatic�n suits, liability, or expe�se, arising from or cc�nnected with services performed under this Agreement. Notwithstanding the foregoing,if as a result of services performed or findings made by Firm relating tt�the investigation, Firm t�r its Attorneys are named as defendants (or respondents,charged p�rties, ar parties of any sort)in any legal action,City will pravid�a defense at its �xpense through its legal cc�unsel, City also will indemnify and hold the Fizm harmless with respect to any judgrnent entered against them or any settlement agreernent {approved in advance by City) that is entered into. This paragraph does not apply to any allegations braught by City against Firm. b. Inde�sendent Contractor Status i. This Agreement is between th�City and Firrn and is nat intended and shall not be construecl to create the relationship of agent, servant, employee; partnership,jc�inti venture;or�ssociation, as between Citiy and Firm. ii. Firm understands and agrees that all Firm personnel furnishing services to City under this Agreement are employees solely of Firm and nc�t of Crty for putposes of work�rs' compensatian liability, Agreement for Professional Serviees � iii. Firm shall bear the sole responsibility and liability for fiirnishing workers' compensati�n benefits to any Firm personnel for injuries arising frc�m services performed under this Agreement. c. Gc�veining Laws This Agreement sha11 l�e ctsnstrued in accardance with the laws of the State of Califomia. d. Record Retentidn and Inspection Within ten�10) days af City's written request, Firm shall allow City or authorized State c�r�`ederal agencies or any du�y authorized representative to have the right to access; exarnine; audit, excerpt, capy, or transcr�ibe any pertinent transactian, activity, time cards, a� other reeords relatinb to this Agreement. Fum shall keep such material, including all pertinent cost accounting, financial records, ancl praprietary data for a period of three (3) years after termination �r completion of this Agreernent unless City°s written peimission is given to dispose of material pric�r to the end of such periad or until such titne as all audits are camplete, �hichever is later. At the expiration af a�y retention period required under this agreement, Firm may destr�y any client files unless City has requested, in writiing, that said files be delivered to City. e. Validity The invalidity in whole or in part of any provisian of this Agreement sha11 not void or affect the valid ity of any oth�r provision. f. Waiver No waiver af a breach of any provisian of this Agreement by either party shall canstitute a waiver of any other breach of the provision c�r any c�ther provision of this Agreement. �'ailure ofeither party to enforce any provision of this Agreement at any time shall not be construed as a waiver of that prc�vision. g. Inte�;ratit�n This Agreement shall constitute the eomplete and exclusive statement of understanding between City and Firm which supersedes all previous written or oral agreements,and all prior communications between the City and Firm retating to the subject matter of this Agreernent. 12. Date of Contract: The effective date of this Contract shall be the date it is exeeuted by Agreement for Professional Services � the City. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, City and Firm have exeeutecl this Contract in Redding, Califarnia, on the days and yea�set forth below; FIRM BIJRKE, WILLIAMS &SORENSEN,LLP Dated: , 2�2b BENJAMIN L. STOCI�,Partner (Taac ID�To. ) CITY Dated; , 242& WILLIAM S. TARBOX City Manager ATTEST: APPROVED AS TQ FC1RM: SHARLENE TIPTON, City Clerk CHRISTIAN M. CURTIS, City Attomey Agreement for Professional Serviees � GG 99 Professional Services Firm will provicie an In#erim City Attorney who, along with �'irm's other attoineys and paralegals as appropriate, shall provide, on an interim basis; General and 5pecial Legal Services normally provided by the City's in-hause City Attom�y. Fiim wzll coordinate with the City Cauncil and General Manager on the allocation of work between Fum and in-house legal staff. City Council retains ultimate authority on the allocation af 1ega1 work, but delegates to the City Manager or his designee the authorit�tt�allocate between Firm and in-house attQi-neys on a day- tc�-d�y'basis. 6G!"�T,1�TL'11A.i� LL'47HJ� 47��1i V 11...�L'�.797 11\l.Lll.1JL'�: LTL'Lr � Attendance at City Cauncil meetings; • Re�vie�v and cornment on City Cauncil agenda items referred by the City Manager; • Research,preparation or review of rautine wrft�en oginions, til'[�itl2lliCC3i resolutions, standard Ci#y template-based agreements, public wurks eontracts and other routine doeurnents of a legal nature r►ecessary or requested by the City Manager, or Ciiy Council; • Respond ta requests for legal advice from City Couneil mernbers, City Manager, department heads and uther design�ted personnei as apprc�priate, • Monitor �nd advise the City Council and �City staff of legislation and case law affecting the City; ! Provide recommendation and advice to the City Manager for the retention of special outside legal counsel, a# the discretian of the City Manager 4n consultation with the City Attorney; • M�nitar acNvities af�ny special outside counsel retained by the City; + Provide conflict of interest assistance to City and staff on behalf af the City and assrsting members and staff in seeking advice from the Fair Po�ihcal P'ractices Cc►mmission; * Provide advice an issues related to the �rown Act(Government Code Section 54950 et seq J; Agreement for Professionat;Services g • Review and advise on standard, nan-complex/non-valuminaus requests under the Public Records Act(Governrnent�'ode Sectio�n 625l� et seq.), • Pr�vide legal advice and cuunsel to commissions and boards and attend commissionlboard/carnrnittee rneetings as deemed necessary by th�City Manager or City Coua�cil; * Represent and advise the City Co�ncil and all City Officers in all rnatters of lavv pertaining to their c►ffices; • Prepare and submit Quarterly Lidigatian Reports briefly outlining the status af each active lifigat�on matter to keep t�e Cily Council and +Cfty Manager inforrned Qf the st�tus of li�igation involving the City, « Provide general redevelopment/successor agency advice; and M Oversee and rnanage the legal affai�-s of the City an+d ta insure the palicies, programs, and activities of the C'ity and its employees and agents are carried out in compliance with all applicable law and that the best interests af the City are otherwise pratected ta the fullest extenf possfble, "SPECIAL LEGAL SERVICES"INGLUDEt • Render advice and assistance to C�ty departments on persc�nnel diseiplinar� and/or labor relati�ns matters, review memoranda of understandin� or ather labor agreements, draft implerneniing legaslafion or pert�nent dacuments and represent City on matters arising from mernoranda of and�rst�nding or the City's gersvnne� rul�s, • Render advice andl assistance to City regarding comp�lex environmentat review u�cluding review and analysis of any documents prep�red tu analyze a prajeet's environmental impacts pursuant to the Califarnia Environmental Quality Act {"�EQ�")j • R�al praperty transactians in which the City is the seller or purchaser, or is involved in any sale/leaseback ar iease/leaseback arrangement, and any other non-routine real estate matters (su�h as CCBrFts, deed or title work), • Negotiati+nn of development agreement, power purchase agreernents or Cammunity Choice Aggregation agreements, and camplex ecanomic developrnent matters, • Revrew and revise agreern�nts that deviate in form frorn the standard Ciiy template; Agreement for Professional Services g • Provide legal caunsel and advice related to redevelapmentJsuecessor housing agency matters, inclading affordable hausing �greements with third party consultants or service pr+nviders; • Represent tl�e City in non-adversarial administrative proceedings, leg�slative hear�inigs, and �ather intergovernmental hearings; • Render advice and assistance in the administratian of�ll claims and eomplaints by or against the City, • Represent the Ciiy, and its offYcers, agents, anrl emplayees in matters in s#ate and federal administrative agencies {such as th� Department of Industrial Relarions, Regional Water +Qualily +Control Baard, I)epartment of Fair Employment and IIousing, Equal Opportunity Cornmissian, Worker's +Compensatior� Appeals Boarc�, etc,), anti • Frovide advice an water and wastewater atulit;y issues {including rates), cable television, telecornmunications, solid waste,�nd other franchise rnatters. Agreement for Frofessional Services lp GG 99 BUR , SORENSEN, WILLIAMS, LLP BILLING RATES General Le�al Serviees Rates: All Attarneys {blended) $335 hr. Paxalegals $225 hr. Special Le�al Services Rates: All Attorneys (blended) $4Q5 hr. P'aralegals $�35 hr. Agreement for Prot`essional Services 11