Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - City Council - 1971-01-04 1 City Council, Regular Meeting Police Dept. & Council Chambers Bldg. Redding, California January 4, 1971 7:00 P.M. The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag was led by Airports Manager McCall. The meeting was called to order at 7:00 P.M. by Vice Mayor Chatfield with the following Councilmen pres ent: Ander son, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield. A.bsent: Mayor Moty A.lso present were City Manager Brickwood, City A.ttorney Murphy, Finance IDirector and Personnel Director Courtney, Public Works Director A.rness , Planning Director Harris , Police Chief Whitmer , Parks Director Blaser, Traffic Engineer Hamilton, A.ssistant Civil Engineer Hastings, Sanitation Superintendent Townsend, A.irports Manager McCall, and City Clerk Brayton. A.PPROVA.L OF MINUTES MOTION:. Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the minutes of the regular meeting of December 21 , � 1970, as mailed to each Councilman. The Vote: Unanimous A.yes C OMMUNI CA TIONS George Dymesich With the approval of Council, Vice Mayor referred to the Planning Commission a communication dated December 18th from George Dymesich requesting consideration for a type of zoning ���� that would permit construction of a 16 story building for senior citizens, to be located adjacent to the Elks Club. City of San Leandro No action was taken by Council re the request of the City of San Leandro for support of legislation which would require � �� the presence of safety warning flares in all vehicles. Vice Mayor Chatfield and Councilman Denny expressed reluctance to support a measure until they had seen the actual bill. William A.lexander MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman ;(��;,/-� Fulton approving the request of William A.lexander for a license to operate as a private patrol operator in the City of Redding. �� L� The Vote: Unanimous Ayes , John Livingston A letter of appreciation was received from John Livingston of Eureka, California, for the goodwill gesture in regard to parking jOU meters for Christmas shoppers in the City of Redding. A.PPROVA.L OF CLAIMS A.ND PAYROLL MOTION: Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded by Councilman Denny that A.ccounts_ Payable Register No. 13, check nos. 12575 to 12701 , inclusive, in the amount of $71,612.41 be approved and paid, and that Payroll Register No. 13, check nos. 34188 through 34473, inclusive, salaries in the amount ��� of $89, 140. 05 for the period December 6 , 1970 through December 19, 1970 be approved.. Total $160, 752.46 Voting was. as follows: A.yes: Gouncilmen - Anderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Moty 2 CLA.IMS FOR DA.MAGES - 2nd hearing Vernon A.dams - Claim filed 12/7/70 MOTION: Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded by ��� Councilman Fulton that the Claim for Damages filed by Vernon A.dams 'on December 7, 1970 be denied, and that the Claimant be so advised. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes � H. T. Barnard ��� MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman A.ndersbn that the Claim for Damages filed by H. T. Barnard on December 7 , 1970 be denied, and that the Claimant be so advised. The Vote: Uriariimous A.yes St. Joseph School j;�:� MOTION: Made by Councilman A.nderson, seconded by Councilman Denny that the Claim for Damages filed by St. Joseph School on November 17; 1970 be denied, and that the Claimant be so advised. T'he Vote: Unanimous A.yes RESOLUTION - re legislation pertaining to litter and waste disposal MOTION: Made by Councilman Fulton, seconded by Councilman Denny that Resolution No. 4399 be adopted, a resolution urging tlie L,eague of ���;;� California Cities and the County Supervisors Association of California to seek action to alleviate the problem of litter and waste disposal created by the sale of products in disposable, non-returnable containers. Voting was as follows: A.yes: Councilmen = A.nderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Moty Resolution No. 4399 on file in the office of the City Clerk. ,. ., A.WA.RD OF BID - Parking Meters MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the recommendation of the Finance Director that Bid Schedule No. 579 , Parking Meters , be awarded to Traffic A.ppliance on their ��;j A.lternate Bid of $99.75 for double meters and $48.30 for single meters, including California Sales Tax. Voting was as follows: A.yes: Councilmen - A.nderson, Denny, Fu.lton, and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen - None Absent: Councilmen - Moty POLICE DEPA.RTMENT - Electronic Corrirnunications Control Center In a memo�to Council dated January 4; 1971 , City Manager Brickwood stated that because of deviations from advertised specifications on Bid Schedule No. 582 , Electronic Communications Control Center, the low bidder and the next lowest bidder are disqualified. Since Motorola's �G� bid was double the budgeted amount of $5 , 000, it is the recommendation of the City Manager that all bids be rejected and the City Manager be authorized to readvertise. MOTION: Made by Councilman A.nderson, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the reconzrnendation of the City Manager that all bids be rejected on Bid Schedule' No. 582, and the City Manager be authorized to readvertise. Voting was as follows: A.yes: Councilmen - A.nderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noe s: C ouncilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Moty 3 AWARD OF CONTRA.CT - City Package Insurance Fina.nce Director Courtney reviewed the proposed Package Insurance Program as contained in his memo to Council dated December 31 , 1970. Mr. Courtney stated that the Independent Insurance A.gents A.ssociation of Shasta County assisted staff with the preparation of the specifications and that specifications were made available to all of the agents with offices in Redding who offer this type of coverage. Bids were opened on December 22nd, and it is the joint recommen- dation of staff and the Independent Insurance A.gents A.ssociation that the contract for the City Package Insurance Program be awarded to Insurance A.ssociates at a net annual premium cost of $71 , 373. Mr. ; Courtney explained that the types of coverage are identical to previous coverage; however, the City will be self-insured in the.amount of $300.00 on property damage liability and $1 , 000. 00 on buildings and contents. A.lthough the annual premium represents a net increase of appro�mately $23, 000. 00, Mr. Courtney said that recognition should be given to the fact that, since the award of the last insurance contract, Twin View A.nnex 1 and 2 have become part of the City; the Clear C reek ��� Sewage Treatment Plant has been constructed and is in operation; the A.uditorium is now in operation, and the City is operating a complete , water and sewer system in the Buckeye A.rea, both inside and outside the City limits, and all of these are added to our building coverage and our liability coverage, Mr. Courtney urged Council to accept the recommendation before them. City Attorney Murphy said that he :concurred fully with the recommen- dation before Council. Gary Green, 2930 Kenco A.venue, appeared before Council as a private citizen and expressed concern over the large increase in the annual premiitm charge. He mentioned that he had called the City of Chico and had determined that their annual insurance premium charge for the year 1969-70 was $19,269 for general coverage of 200-500 thousand dollars and 100 thousand dollars property damage. Mr. .Courtney re.plied that it i�s not appropriate to compare R.edding with the City of Chico as Chico does not operate a water utility, an electric utility, or garbage and refus:e collection and disposal' service. ` Mr..-.Gr�e�en referred to the.articLe in the.newspaper whi`ch stated -that Redding is helping to pay for�th�e larger cities: He a>sked Mr^. Nye� (a member of the firm, Insurance A.ssociates) how the premium � � charges are determined, whether by underwriters' arbitrary recom- mendations or from�rate schedules :. He' also= questioned the reasori t�at there were so few bidder:s: . . , , � Mr. Nye said that the rates are,taken from .rate.books; �and he:mentioned that many insurance companies refuse to bid on municipal contracts be caus.e of pa st expe:ri enc�e. - � � �� Mr; Green also questioned the fee on the binder coverage. - � Vice. Mayor Chatfield said-that the binder will not result. 'in extra cost to the City if �Counc;il appr.oves. awarding the bid to-Insurance A.s sociates . However, if Council does not.�acc:ept the bid, the City will need the binder and will have to pay an extra charge for the binder as�it will take at least 30 days to readvertise for bids and award a contract. Mr. Gr.een said that�an-=increase of $23, 000.00 in annual preriiiums seem:phenomenal, and he believes the City should seek bid proposals from other insurance agents in other cities . 4 Mr. Nye said there were 10 agents who received invitations to bid, and he believes there were at least 10 insurance companies contacted, and yet there were only two bidders. He mentioned that insurance agents in Chico are represented by the same insurance companies as agents in Redding. Mr. Michael Giddings, Lake Royal A.partments, who is an insurance broker, asked if either of the bidders met the specifications. He was advised that the specifications were not met exactly by either bidder. Mr. Giddings said that if this were tr.ue, he felt the package program should be rebid. He also questioned how the binder fee was arrived at. Mr. Nye said it was calculated on a short° rate basis on the total premium. Mr. Giddings stated that he did not agree that this was the proper basis .for calculating a binder fee. Mr. Huffaker, a local insurance agent, spoke of working with staff in preparing the specifications and said there are considerations that have to be taken into account. He stated that three years ago the City re- ceived an extremely good rate, and it was guaranteed for the full three years which is quite uncomrrion. Since that time, rates have increased many, many times and the City's 'insurance cost has not. Mr. Huffaker said.that there were certain exceptions to the specifi- cations which were called to the attention of. the low bidder , and it was the recommendation of the Insurance A.gents Association that if the specifications could not be met, the bid should be awarded to the next lowest bidder. The low bidder was given several days in which to contact his company but he was unable to comply with the specifica- tions . Mr. Huffaker said that he feels that the business at hand is that Council has been asked to make a decision. He pointed out that he did not provide a bid but feels that staff came up with a good recommendation. He further stated that he would be happy to discuss the matter with Gary Green after the meeting to try to answer his � que s tions. .��/ There was considerable discussion between Council and staff about the merits of higher deductibles in order to reduce insurance cost. In answer to Councilman Anderson's inquiry as to whether it would be possible to amend or endorse the policy if Council were to award the contract this evening, he was advised that this would be possible without cost penalty if changes were made on the policy anniversary date. Mr. Denny asked what would happe.n if the City did not get any bids . City Attorney Murphy replied that the City would be self-insured or could negotiate with insurance brokers. Mr. Denny then asked if there are any limits of liability that the citizens of the community would be liable for in the case of.self-insurance. Mr. Murphy said he knows of no State law that puts a ceiling .on limits of liability. Mr. Jack Rodgers of the insurance firm Rodgers and Bryant said that he had nothing to add except to point out that, although his firm was the lowest bidder but did not meet the specifications , neither did the second lowest bidder. He said that if Council should decide to: rebid the insurance package program, he believes there should be some clarification of the ground rules . Mr. Courtney said that the areas where both bidders did not meet the specifications were not specific coverage areas defined in the specifications , but they were implied to be included in the specifica- ti ons . ; ! 5 Councilman.Chatfield asked if both bidders failed .to meet the.. specifications re liability for loss as a result of riot or civil � commotiori or,:failure to supply water_or _electric power . He was advised that the bid of the firm of Rodgers and Bryant was silent in this regard but that later Mr . Rodgers stated that his i company said they would have to make the same exception as was..disclosed in.writing by Insurance Associates. � Mr.. Denny asked if these exceptions, constitute non-conformance, I and the City. A.ttorney. said that staff took the position that they did. Councilman Fulton expressed concern that Council had not been briefed in more detail pr.ior to .this evening as he feels .it is diffi- cult to make a decision without giving the matter more study. Mr. Courtney explained that he had started to put the program together in September and that staff..and members of the Indepen- dent Insurance Agents A.s sociation had put in many, many hours preparing the specifications . He also mentioned that originally the bids were .scheduled to be opened on December 15th but there had been.a request for a.one week .extension which was :granted by staff. . This made it impossible to present the ,program.to Council at its .meeting. of.December2lst. Mr. Courtney said he intends to start working on the 1974-1977 program the A.pril before the pro- ' posed contract expires in December, 1973, Council:man Denny said, assuming that in the.opinion of__the ,Committee or staff.the two bids.were comparable in all respects.other than limits of liability as stated heretofore, does the Committee make its recom- mendation on the grounds that Insurance A.ssociates is taking into account those limits? Mr. Cour.tney said that the policy. that.Insuranc.e Associate.s offers is , as-.their bid states,. whereas the policy.offer,ed by Ro.dgers and Bryant , is not-as the bid states . . -. . � : _ . , Mr. Murphy added that the. reason the Cornmittee -is_ recommending the . higher of the two bids is that this bid is an unchanged bid from the day �`�I ' of the bid opening. The other bid has caused two meetings of the Coxnmittee.,. repeated conferences with the bidding coxnpany, and it is , the C,ity's.understanding that .the policy we would,receive,.fxom the low bidder�.would:be substa•ntially different from that specified in the bid a:s it was presented:. •:�.. . Mr. Huffaker stated that, as a member of the Committee, the low bid � of Rodgers� and Bryant was changed ,verbalTy.. at the: opening; and, then ' becaus.e of aome deficlencies ,..separate committee meetings were held , and Rodger.s and Bryant.were given several days to discuss the matter ! with their carrier and straighten these matters out.. It was the Com- mittee's f.eeling.that it was "lrke leaving:money:.on�the table and then i coming,back to.pick it up. " The Committee believes tliat if you are going � to have a bidding procedure and if ..someone ha.s left money on the table, they should.not.be allowed. to come_back and pick it up°and still stay low. The.,Committee felt that this was the.;effe,ct of what was happening. Ther.•e was discussion as to �the .advisability of approving the contract on a: one-y.ear basis and then possibly not going.on a package deal in the future. It was pointed out that the policy could be cancelled at � its anniversary date without any penalty to the City. MOTION: Made by Gouncilrnan,Denny, seconded by .Councilman A.nderson appr.oving bhe recommendation of staff and the Independent Ins.urance. A.gents :A.ssociation that the Package Insuranee Contract � for the per.iod January 1 , 1971 through December 31 , .1973 be awarded I 6 to Insuranc.e A.s s ociate s on their bfd of $71; 37 3.00, annual net pr emium. Voting was as follows: � Ayes: Coizncilmen - Anderson, Denny, Fulton, .and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen - None - ' - Absent: CounciYmen - Moty PUBLIC HEA.RING - Curb, Gutter, and Sidewaik Construction Project, Pha s e V The hour of 8:00 P.M. having arrived, Vice Mayor Chatfield opened the Public Hearing'on Phase V, Cu'rb, Gutter; and Sidewalk 'Construction Project: ``The following d`ocuments are on file in the office of the City Cle rk: Declaration of Mailing and Posting of Notice of Public Hearing - ' Report of the Superintenderit of Streets ' - ' The City Clerk advis ed Council.that a written protest had � - been received from A.lbert A. Geiger, stating that he does not want curb and gutter on Parcel 108-210-29�,' Block 6, Sliasta Gardens Subdivision, Unit 1 , Lot 5`. -Millie G.- IDecker also`subrnitted a protest on the cost of construction of sidewalk on her-pr`operty at 1523 Olive Ave'nu:e, as the cost quoted was $392.00 and the cost cliarged was� $432 .03. - - - - A.ssistant Civil Engineer Hastings said that the Geiger prvperty consists of two lots on�Riviera Drive which a're vacant. Curbs and gutters were complete in this particular block except for �c;� the Geiger property. Mr. Geiger did not appear before Council and protest during the first hearing. � ' � ' ���- ` Regarding Mrs . Decker, there was an error inade in the billing sent to Mrs. Decker,' and Mr. Hastings recomrriended that an adjustment be made which would reduce the charge to $354:03: He stated that a favorable bid on the project caused the reduc- tion from the original quote of $392. 00 to $354. 03. ' George Cole appeared on behalf of Charles Christy, 2334 Californ'ia Street', as Mr. Christy is in Southern Califor'nia: " Mr: Cole said that Mr. Christy is not complaining about the price but he does not believe the installation was done properly because, since the installation of the curbs and gutters, water. floods into his basement. �Mr: Hastings explained that the flooding occurred during the heavy rains when water going into a catch basin apparently ' '� rari into a'drainage clitch on pr operty owned by the Native �Daughters.. �Mr. Hastings refreshed Council regarding the � previous hearing on this construction project at which time " the drainage problem on the property of the Native Daughters was discussed in detail. The Native Daughters intend to fill tlie drainage ditch which will correct the flooding problem of Mr. Christy. The City will block the 18" stub out of the catch basin until such time as the 18" drainage pipe is extended into the alley. It was pointed out that the catch basin was installed at City expense and there was no charge against Mr.- Christy for the basin. - Mr . Wright of 2349 California Street questioned the charge of $10 .75 per lineal foot for curb, gutter, arid sidewalk installed on the front portion of his property versus $7.00 per lineal foot charge for similar installation on the back portion of his � property. He also not�ed that tliere 'was a shortage of 2-1/2 ftt: of curb and gutter. Mr. Hastings will meet with Mr. Wright tomorrow morning to discuss the above matter. � � 7 ' City A.ttorney Murphy said that if any clerical errors have ° been made, the Gity will make whatever adjustments are necessary. � ' ' ' ' Iv10TION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by � � Councilman Fulton that the Public Hearing be closed. The " ' � Vote: Unanimous A.yes � ' � IRESOLUTION - Confirming Report of Superintendent of Streets MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, sec'onde'd by Councilman - ` Fizlton that 'Re'solutiori=No": 4400 Ue adopted, a resolution of the � �City Council of tlie City of Redding confirming the Report of the Superintendent of Streets on the cost of construction of certain improvements in certain designated locations in the City of Reddirig, and makirig asse"ssmerits to pay the cost thereof. Voting was as follows: ' Ayes: Councilmen - A.nderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen .-_1Vone _ . _. - _ - ... , _ . . . , A.bsent: Gotzncilmen - Moty ` � � . � , I Resolution No. 4400 on file in the office of the City Clerk. A.WARD OF BID - A.irport and'Hangar Keepers' Liability MOTION: Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded'by Counc'rlman Fulton approving the recommendation of staff and representatives of the Independent Insurance Agents A.ssociation'of Sliasta'Gounty that the Airport,Liability and Hangar Keepers' Liability Insurance Goritract v�-�� be awarded to to Insurance A.ssociates on their bid of $6',9'7>4" for three year prepaid premium for the period January l, 1971 through December 31, 1973. Voting was as follows:. � A.yes: Councilmen -'A.nderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield � Noes: Councilmen - None Absent:� Councilmen - Moty � Vice Mayor Chatfield appointed Councilman Denny and Councilman � A.ndersori to a committee to evaluate the City's insurance program ; a'ncl report back to Council with recommendations-in approximately four months. � � � CA.SCA.DE BLVD. ANNEX NO. 1 In a`�memo` to Gouncil dated December 30, 1970, which memo is made a part of these minutes` by reference, it was the recommendation of ' the Plarinin'g Director and staff that the City Council not approve the ;��J� annexation proceedings re Cascade Blvd•. A.nnex No. 1 for the reasons � s et forth in said memo. � MOTION: Made by Councilman Fulton, secorided by Councilman Denny approving the recommendation of the Planning Director re Cascade Blvd .A.nnex No. 1 , as set forth above. The Vote: Unanimous A.yes PAFtKING STUDY, 1970 In a memo to C`ouncil dated December 30 , 1970, the Traffic:.and Parkirig Commission`set fortli its eridors'ement of all proposal in the Parkirig Study, 1�970 with the following additiona�l comments: " ' Page 23,' Item 2', recommeridsthe adoption of a single " , rate structure of five cents per hourr T1ie�Cbxnmission concurs, and wishes to emphasize further that it opposes ��r'�� increasing rates should additional revenues be needed. Page 25, Item 6(d), recommends the improvement and metering of Center Street and Sacramento Street behind ���/�' Rother Auto Parts . The' Commission's endorsement is conditional upon development of plans which prove feasibility. 8 Regarding the proposed parking structures, the Commission - feels strongly that a system of parking fee collection by atten- dant will better serve the interests of the mall shoppers by removing the pressure to return to a ticking meter . If, however, meters are select ed as the means: of collection, :the Commission recommends that three-hour meters be used in the shopper-oriented sections to permit an extended shopping period. It is the recommendation of the Traffic Engineer that the parking study, together with the recommendations of the Traffic and Parking Commission, be referred to Couneilman Deriny; as the Council-Member designated re- sponsible for parking departmental activities. With the approval of Council, Vice>Mayor Chatfield ref:erred the above matter to Councilman Denny. - . , PUBLIC WORKS MONTHLY PLANNING REPORT �%U Public Works Director Arness sub•mitted the Public Works Monthly Planning Report for the month of December, 1970. TRUNK SEWER FEE Public Works Director Ar,ness submitted the Construction Cost Index as of De'cember 31 , 1970 as follows: - " , ��� Erigineering News-Reco,rd : 330 .West 42nd Street , - New; Y.o-rk, N.Y. 10036 - December 10, 1970 , Construction Cost Index - December 10, 19.70 San Franci•sco, California - 1598.08 The index places the trunk sewer construction fee prescribed under Section 23-20(c), Redding City Code, at $572. 13 MOTION: Made by Go:�uncilman Denny, ,s econded by Councilman Fulton approving the trunk sewer construction fee at $572. 13. per acre for the period January 1 , 1971 through June 30, 1971. The Vote: U.nanimous A.yes RESOLUTION - re TOPICS Improvement Project �� , MOTION:� Made 'by Councilman Fulton, seconded by Coizncilman-De;nny ' that Resolution No. 4401 be adopted, a resolution of the City Council of ,� .���� the City of Redding approving the Shasta=Market Streets Signalization Project as a TOPICS Improvement Project. , Voting was as follows: Ayes: Councilmen - Anderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noes: � Councilmen - None Absent: - _Councilmen - Moty - � . . Resolution No. 4401 on file in the office of the City Clerk. RESOLUTION - A.cquisition of Kutras Parcel 5 - Turtle Bay MOT-ION; Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded by:Gouncilman Fulton that Resolution. No. 4402 be adopted, a resolution of-the City Council of the City of Redding approving the purchase of Kutras Parcel 5 , Turtle Bay, and authorizing the execution by the Mayor of the necessary .��U docume-nts to ace.omplish such .purchase. - Voting was as follows: � Ayes: Councilmen - Anderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield • Noes: Councilmen - None ;.... Absent: Councilrnen - Moty Resolution No. 4402 on file in the office of the City Clerk. 9 AIRPORT LA.ND USE COMMISSION MOTION: Made by Councilman A.nderson, seconded by Councilman Denny ratifying the action taken by Mayor Moty in endorsing Resolution No. 70-177 of the Board of Supervisors of the County of Shasta finding ;�'y� that proper land use planning in the vicinity of airports can best be accomplished by the planning agency presently having jurisdiction. ' The Vote: Unanimous Ayes � LEA.SE EXTENSION - Senior Citizens of Shasta County, Inc. , MOTION: Made by Councilman Anderson, seconded by Councilman � Fulton approving the extension of lease between the City of Redding -��Gi�� and the 5enior Citizens of Shasta County, Inc. , to June 30 , 1971 , and authorizing the Vice Mayor to execute said document. The Vote: Una.nimous Ayes RESOLUTION - Acquisition of Property - Redding Municipal Airport MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman A.nderson that Resolution No. 4403 be adopted, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Redding declaring that the public convenience and , � necessity require the acquisition of an interest in certain real property j/ c�' for a public improvement, to wit, for the establishment of clear zones at Redding Municipal A.irport, and authorizing eminent domain pro- ceedings therefor. (Dunton) Voting was as follows: A.yes: Councilmen - A.nderson, Denny, Fulton, and Chatfield Noes: Councilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Moty Resolution No. 4403 on file in the office of the City Clerk. ROUTINE COMMUNICATIONS Shasta-Cascade Wonderland Association publicity re hunting ��/ � in Shasta County PUC Order Instituting Investigation re procedures for use in � 7� determining California intrastate operating results of inter- state bus carriers operating in California Notice of Hearing before PUC re application of Standard Air Cargo Consolidators Corp. as an A.ir Freight Forwarder of .� 7� general commodities between points in State of California Building Activity Report - Month of November, 1970 ��`G A.DJOURNMENT There being no further business, at the hour of 10:05 P.M. , on the motion of Councilman A.nderson, seconded by Councilman Denny, the meeting was adjourned. A.PPROVED: 1 ,� � � ,,, � , � ic e Mayor i A.TTEST: - , , � / � , , _�l.l-:C��Z;[.Z.cZJ ,���i- ,;=�C�'12�, C ity�..Cl�e rk �� J