Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - City Council - 1972-05-15 71 City Council, Regular Meeting Police Dept. & Council Chambers Bldg. Redding California May 15, 1972 7:00 P. M. The Pledge of A.11egiance to the Flag was led by Robert Whitmer, Chief of Polic e. The invocation was offered by the Reverend Glen Parks , Pastor of the A.ssembly of God Church. The meeting was called to order at 7.�:;00 P.M, by Mayor Moty with the following Councilmen present: Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty. Absent: Councilman A.nderson. A.lso present were City Manager Brickwood, City Attorney Murphy, Finance Director and Personnel Director Courtney, Public Works Director Arness , Planning Director Harris , Police Chief Whitmer , Police Sergeant Stone, Parks Director Riley, A.irports Manager McCall, Sewage Treatment Plants Superintendent Hiler , and Deputy City Clerk Richter . APPROVA.L OF MINUTES MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the minutes of the regular meeting of May 1 , 1972, as mailed to each Councilman. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes MONOLITH Planning Director Harris reported that the proposal submitted by the Chamber for the improvement of the concrete monolith was reviewed jointly by the Staff and representatives of the Chamber Corrunittee. The Staff endorses the basic concept of the rehabilitation; however, several questions should be resolved before the project is formally approved and any construction is commenced. The points discussed are as follows: l. A.s the structure is now and will remain a dominate feature of Turtle Bay, any improvements or development must be carefully integrated into the development plans for the Park itself. 2. The project as proposed is only schematic and more precise plans are necessary in order to obtain reliable cost estimates . I/��� `T 3. A.lthough we do not wish to discourage a volunteer program of improvement, we do feel that any effort in this regard must be carefully coordinated to insure end result desired by both the city and the •volunteer groups involved. It is the recommendation of the Staff that the following program be approved: l . 'Tlie Chamber of Commerce Committee be encouraged to proceed with the initial clean up of the structure such as removal of the dirt and gravel on the top of the structure and general cleaning around the base. This should help considerabl�! in the appearance of the monolith. We feel it may be premature to clean the face of the structure by .sand blasting at this time and that any grading should await the development of more detailed plans . 2. The City Staff be directed to prepare the more precise development plans for Turtle Bay and the structure. 3. When the plans are completed and cost estimates established, the City and Chamber of Commerce Committee should meet and determine the most feasible course of action relating to construc- tion of any improvements and how the program can best be implemented. I 72 Mr. Sid Cowgill, Manager of the Redding Chamber of Commerce requested that a priority be established for the project. He suggested that State or Federal �Funds might now be available for the project. He stated that time and i aterials will be donated as far as is possible. Planning Director Harris reiterated the need to establish a design concept for the entire, 200 acre Turtle Bay Park. Time must be allowed for engineering studies , and the development plans should be coordinated with tlie Recreation and Parks Commission. The availability of State or Federal Funds wi11 be investigated. Staff will place a priority to the project according to direction from Council. Mayor Moty advised that priorities for parks development will be discussed at budget sessions , and Mr. Cowgill will be invited to attend such sessions . BUDGET City Manager Brickwood submitted the 1972-73 Preliminary Budget. ��� Budget study session was set for Thursday, May 25 , 1972, 1:00 P. M. , in the Mayor' s Conference Room. C OMMUNICA.TIONS Lassen View School Students A. comrriunication received from Students as Lassen View ��� School, Cluster IV, Level 6, regarding use of City property on Cypress Avenue as a park was referred to the City Manager for reply. Kay Hendricks A con�zunication was received from Kay Hendricks, 1613 Deschutes Jl �� Road, Palo Cedro, California, protesting the removal of regular traffic signals at the corner of Shasta and Court Streets . City Manager Brickwood was directed to reply to the letter. Ore�on Trail Riders - � . The City Clerk received a communication from the Oregon Trail Riders on May 8, requesting permission to sell beer at their open hqrse show and playday to be held at the arena grounds at Redding Municipal A.irport on May 13 and 14. Council was ��� polled by tel'ephone regarding this matter and all members indicated approval. � MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton ratifying the action taken by Council in a telephone poll approving thie request as outlined above. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes Shasta County Sheriff's Posse-ettes MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Gouncilman Fulton approving the request of the Shasta County Sheriff's �� � Posse-ettes to sell beer at their annual Silver Spur Horse Show on June 24, j1972, at the Rodeo Grounds on Butte Street. The Vote: �nanimous Ayes City of Redding Employees';. Association MOTION: Made by Councilman Fulton, seconded by Councilman Denny approving the request of the Redding City Employees' ��� Association to sell beer at the Shasta County Sheriff's Posse Rodeo on May 26 and 27, at the Posse Grounds . The Vote: Unanimous A.yes �// Coleman Grocery "/V�/� Mayor Moty requested the City Clerk to enter the following letter from Franklin S. Cibula Dated May 9 , 1972 , into the minutes in full: 73 City Council City of Redding 760 Parkview A.venue Redding, CA. 96001 Re: Coleman Grocery Gentlemen: Thi•s office represents Mr. and Mrs . Curtis Coleman and Leo Coleman, owners of Coleman Grocery at 1855 Linden Avenue, Redding, California. Without prior notice to Mr. Coleman, Mrs . Purley Harrison, owner of ABC Grocery and Burger Shop at 2801 West Street, Redding, California, and Mrs . Dorris A.nderson appeared at a City Council meeting on Monday, May l , and made certain charges . Quoting from the Record-5earchlight of Tuesday, May 2, 1972, it is stated as follows: "Mrs . Purley Harrison, owner of the ABC Grocery and Burger Shop at 2801 West St. accused Curtis Coleman,owner of Coleman's Grocery at 1855 Linden Ave. , of promoting gambling, illegal drinking and the sale of liquor without a license through his grocery store. "Anywhere you find him (Coleman), you're going to find trouble," Mrs. Harrison said, as she toldr.the council of alleged incidents of gambling with dice, fighting, and the sale of beer and wine without a license. She complained that the activities at Coleman's store were upsetting the neighborhood and causing her to lose business at her store. Mrs. Harrison was backed up in her allegations by Mrs . Dorris Anderson, a resident in the area. "It (Coleman's grocery store) is just a cover up for gambling," Mrs. Anderson.told the council. "We've been through all this before. " Redding Detective Lt. Robert Coulter backed up the two women's ��� allegations . "I'm sure that there has been gambling and there is gambling there," he told councilmen. "But they have someone watching for the police and it's all gone by the time we get there." As a matter of setting the record completely straight, my clients deny that they have ever in any manner promoted gambling, illegal drinking or the sale of liquor without a license through the grocery store. This is not only an untrue charge, it is pure slander . In this regard the attention of the City Council is called to the application of Mr . Curtis Coleman and Mr . Leo Coleman for a beer and wine off=sale license in order that they might obtain legal permission to sell. It is a fact that at the present there is no beer or wine �sold ati:the premises and my clients are doing everything possible to eomply with the law. My clients deny that there is any trouble where Mr. Coleman�is present. A.s to any incidents of gambling with dice, fighting or the sale of beer or wine without a license, any statements that this was done by the Colemans are absolutely untrue. As to the charge that the neighborhood is being upset, my clients will be happy to produce a great proportion of the neighborhood who are not only in favor of his operation of the grocery store, but who would be very happy that a beer and wine off-sale license was allowed on the Coleman premises. When the premises was posted for a beer and wine license the only protestors in the whole neighborhood were the Harrisons. As you know, under the law, the neighborhood had 30 days to enter any protest they had in mind and no one in the neighborhood, except the Harrisons , entered an official protest. 74 The statement that the grocery store is a cover for gambling is absolute slander . With respect to any statements by the Redding City Police that there was any gambling on the Coleman premises , this is absolutely false. What is a fact is that the Redding City Police find no violation of the gambling or sale of liquor laws when they do investigate falicious charges by Mrs . Har 'rison. The Redding City Police log will show that the only complaints ligged with the police are by Mrs . Harrison. Since the City Council meeting, Mr. Coleman has met with the , Redding Police Department and the.y have verified his position that he has never been, found in any illegal activity at the grocery store. l It should be pointecl. out that the Linden Avenue neighborhood con- tinues to be the sourc'e of a very subtle discrimination. There is no liquor license in the comtnunity along Railroad Avenue except at "Jomars Place." The Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control has indicated that it takes the remarkable position that although it knows that the Linden A.venue Residents are drinking outside the area and purchasing liquor and spirits and bringing them back to the area, that it would be against public policy to allow any off-sale beer and wine store in the Linden A.venue area. ; This is a pre,poster.ous point,of view as it only causes the Linden A.venue residents to have to drive in their automobiles out of their neighborhood to buy a bottle of beer or wine. When the beer is brought back into the area there is no single place for the residents to congregate. When certain individuals do congregate, apparently Mrs. Harrison takes objection and blames a problem of civic origin on Mr. Coleman. It is true that the Linden Avenue residents need better protection by the police in thei-r own neighborhood. Mr. Coleman is not the policeman for the City of Redding, he receives no salary and does not wear a badge. ��/ He does his very best to run a.peaceful store and keep the peace within his irr�iediate premises. He has absolutely no right to stop anybody from drinking outside the store or to take any action which would consti- tute police power unless there is a clear violation of law. Mr. Coleman has seen no violations of law as his observations have been exactly that as of the police. The City of Redding is being used by Mrs. Harrison by her constant complaints , when her true concern is apparently for lack of business . The City of Redding should not be trying to help Mrs. Harrison obtain business . If she cannot obtain customers , she should not call the police and try to cause trouble to a neighborhood competitor. This is the most vicious kind of t(ctic and City of Redding should not be a party to it. �: Any investigation or review of Mr. Coleman's permit can only result in their finding that he obeyed the law and his City license should continue. If the City of Reddingitakes any position that a competitor's complaints are grounds for removal of that license, the matter will be considered action- able and unjust takingl by the City of valuable property as well as an unlawful act on the part of its �fficers . Mr. Coleman would not have br.ought this matter to your attention had the false charges not been made. As they have been made, they are denied in full. It is suggested that the City deal with the problem of false reports by the Harrisans in the manner provided by law. It is respectfully required that :this letter be read in full at the council meeting and be entered in the official minutes as an agenda item and that this office be notified'of any hearing on the matter should the council have any questions. Very truly yours , , CIBULA & CIBULA. / Franklin S. Cibula 75 PUBLIC HEA.RING - Planned Development Application PD- 1-72 The hour of 7:30 P.M. having arrived, Mayor Moty opened the Public Hearing on Planned Development A.pplication PD-1-72 The following documents are on file in the office of the City Clerk: Affidavit of Publication - Notice of Public Hearing Affidavit of Mailing - Notice of Public Hearing Report of Planning Director dated May 12, 1972 The City Clerk advised Council that no written protests had been received, and the Mayor ascertained that there were no protests from the floor. Planning Director Harris reviewed his report to Council dated May 12, 1972, which report is made a part of these minutes by reference. He showed the area proposed for planned development by Shahinian and Rogers , Inc. on the Vu Graph. He then submitted maps and explained the various phases of the proposed development in detail. /��, The property is located at the southeast quandrant of Interstate 5 and State Highway 299 East, and includes 71+ acres. The plan as applied for includes a mobilehome park with 199 units and a "Townhouse- Condominium" apartment development with 61 units . The plan provides for approximately 40 acres of Open Space. The Planning Commission and the Staff recommended that the City Council approve the Planned Development application, subject to the twenty conditions outlined in his report. Councilman Chatfield expressed concern about the narrow 24' and 30' private streets . He asked if approval of the design by the Council, would place a liability on the City in the event fire trucks were unable to bypass parked cars in an emergency. Mr. Coyle, representing the developer , informed Council that parking will be prdiibited on the aforementioned streets and that this� regulation will be enforced by the Home Owners A.ssociation. He stated that the plan provides two off-street parking spaces per dwelling plus visitor parking in nearby areas . City A.ttorney Murphy advised that if a condition of ''no parking" on the 24-foot width and the 30-foot width streets is incorporated in the Ordinance, the City would be absolved of liability in the event fire trucks or sanitation packer.s were unable to gain access to the area because of parked cars . MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton that the Public Hearing be closed. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the recommendation of the Planning Commission that the Planned Development Application PD- 1-72 be approved, subject to the twenty conditions , and that parking be prohibited on the 24-foot width and 30-foot width streets, and instructing.the City Attorney to prepare the necessary ordinance. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes THE :.CENTER Mr. Jack Reiser, representing the Redding Rotary Club, submitted an outline and estimated budget for the proposed Teen Center . The concept for "The Center" has been endorsed by the Rotary Clubs of Redding, Enterpr:ise and Anderson, and by the United Crusade . Tim Cartwright, Shasta High Student Body President; spoke about the plan �j � for organization. He advised that there will be a large base of youth and adults on the Board of Directors , with area wide support. They propose 76 to hire a full time.paid coordinator . Membership shall be open to high school age and college age through twenty. Keith Wilson, Enterp�ise High Studerit Body President reported that the group is looking for a building that has approximately three thousand to five thousand square feet; that will accomodate ninety,.to one hundred :fifty people; with a large gathering room, a food services area, and smaller rooms for study activities and music . $300. per month has been budge�ed for rent. Gary Davis , Central Valley High Student President e�lained the program as follows: j 1 . Coordinated Ihole area programs 2. Activities in Central Valley, Redding, Anderson, and Enterprise 3. Satellite Centers 4. Community Service Projects Don Miller , Agape House representative, outlined the plan for financing. It ispropo:sed that the youth will raise one='third of the total budget of ' $51 , 500. They are requesting support from public agencies as follows: A.REA POPULATION °�o TOTA'.L SHA.RE REDDING 18,845 29 $ 9, 135.00 A.NDERSON . 5 ,492 9 2, 835.00 SHASTA. CO. Target:A.rea.. .. ��' l . Enter,prise (�PUD) 11 ,486 11 3,465. 00 2. SHA.STA DAM ('PUD) 5 ,818 40,818 9 2, 835. 00 ' 3� SHASTA CO. (SUPERS)23 ,481 42 13,230. 00 ':Total 'PopizTatYon�;s:erved:by.'Ceiit'er' 65:, 1':55 _ $31, 500.00 The funds received will be controlled by the Board, and the group would like to receive the funds on a monthly basis . The group now has funds to operate for ninety days . They are most anxious to have a definite commitment from the agencies by July 1 s.t in order to continue the program. Mayor Moty expressed concern that under the proposal, the citizens of incor- porated areas would be taxed twice for "The- Center" . The City of Redding residents pay twenty percent of the County taxes , so they�would be paying their own share and twenty percent of the County's share. He suggested that an area-wide Recreation District or Center District would be the proper approach. Ward Gandy stressed�that there is an immediate need for funds to keep the present program active and said that if it is successful for one year, other methods of finai cing could be sought. Mayor Moty said the i equest will be taken under advisement. A.PPROVA.L OF ACCOUNTS PA.YA.BLE AND PA.YROLL MOTION; Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Chatfield that Accounts Payable Register No. 22, check nos .20124 to 20307, inclusive, in the amount of $154�, 831 . 15 be approved and paid, and that Payroll Register No. 23, check nos . 44317 to 44611 inclusive, salaries in the amount of $97 ,612. 92� for the period A.pr.il 23, 1972 through May 6, 1972 ld� be approved. Total $252,444. 07 Voting was as follows: Ayes: Councilm.en ;- Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None Absent: Councilmen.= Anderson 1 C LA.IMS FOR DAMA.GE AND PERSONA.L INJURY - 1 st hearing First Presbyterian Church - Claim filed 5/5/72 MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Denny that the Claim for Darrage filed by First Presbyterian Church �a� of Redding on May 5, 1972, be referred to the City A.ttorney and the City Insuranae Carrier , and the City Clerk be instructed to reset the Claim on the agenda for the meeting of June 19 , 1972 The V ote: Unanimou s A.ye s { 77 Harry Williams - Claim f'iled 5/8/72 MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman ��� Denny that the Claim for Personal Injury filed by Harry Williams on May 8, 1972 be referred to the City Attorney and the City Insurance Carrier, and the City Clerk be instructed to reset the Claim on the Agenda for the meeting of June 19, 1972. The Vote: Unanimous A.yes A.rthur Feise - Claim filed 5/11/72 MOTION: Made by Councilman Fulton, seconded by Councilman /�� Chatfield that the Claim for Damage filed by Arthur Feise on May 11, 1972 be referred to the City Insurance Committee for a a report to Council at the meeting of June 5, 1972. The Vote: Unanimous A.yes CYPRESS AVENUE PROPERTY Planning Director Harris submitted a report of the Planning Commission dated May 11, 19'72. The Corruz�.ission conducted a hearing on the disposal of certain City-owned land located along Cypress Street as shown on the exhibit map attached to the report. ,=;2C7� The Commission determined that the disposal of the land was in conformance with the City's General Plan as adopted and recornmended to the City Council that parcels A., B, C, and D be disposed of. The Corrunission further recommended that parcel E, adjacent to the proposed park site, not be disposed of at this time. Mayor Moty referred the report to the Council Committee on Surplus Land. FLY-IN BREA.KFA.ST , Airports Manager McCall presented the recommendation of the A.irports Commission dated May 12, 1972, that the Redding Jaycees be granted permission to hold a Fly-In Breakfast at Benton Airpark on June 11 , 1972. l�f MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfi��:d, seconded by Councilman Denny approving the request of the Redding Jaycees to hold a Fly-In Breakfast at Benton A.irpark on June 11 , 1972. The Vote: Unanimous. A.yes A.WARD OF BID - Benton Loop-Phase II MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton accepting the recommendation of the Department of Public Works that Bid Schedule No. 621, Benton Loop-Phase II 12-inch Transmission Line, ��� . be awarded to James E. Byrne on his low bid of $14,990. Uoting was as follows: AYES: Councilmen - .Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Anderson AWARD OF BID - Addition to Terminal Building Municipal Airport MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Denny accepting the recommendation of the Department of Public Works and the A.irports Manager that Bid Schedule No. 623, construction of addition ��� to terminal building at Redding Municipal A.irport be awarded to , K. R. Whitmire Company on their low bid of $30,727. Voting was as follows: Ayes: Councilmen - Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None Absent: Councilmen - A.nderson AWA.RD OF BID - 10-Place T Hangar Benton Airpark MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Denny accepting the recommendation of the Department of Public Works and /c�/ the Airports Manager that Bid Schedule No. 624 construction of 10-place T Hangar at Benton A.irpark be awarded to Knighten-Gallino Construction, Inc. , on their low bid of $40, 102. Voting was as follows: Ayes: Councilmen - Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None Absent: Councilmen - A.nderson I i 78 � C LEA.R CREEK A.ND TWIN VIEW SEWA.GE TREA.TMENT FA.CILITIES ���� Public Works Director Arness submitted the Clear Creek and Twin View Sewa e Treatment Facilities Report for the monthsof March,and"� -'. . April, 19� NOTICE OF COMPLETION - 12KV Feeder Lines T✓IOTION: Made by C�ouncilman Chatfield, seconded by Co.uncilman Fulton accepting the project re construction of underground 12KV Feeder Lines on portions of Yuba S�treet between Oregon Street and the Pine-East A.11ey, Bid Schedule No. 591 , as being completed satisfactorily, and ��� authorizing the City Clerk to file the Notice of Completion. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes �I Director of Public Works A.rness requested that final payments not be made until clearance�is granted by the City Attorney and the Finance Director because of a change of ownership within the Tyee Construction Company. RESOLUTION - Turtle Bay East Fishing Access MOTION: Made by Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton that Resolution No. 72-42 be adopted, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Redding approving lease, cooperative agreement and construction agreement with the State of California Wildlife Conservation ���� Board for Turtle Bay East Fishing Access , and authorizing the Mayor to execute said leas e and agr eements . � Voting was as follows: Ayes: . Councilmen - Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None A.bsent: Councilmen - Anderson Resolution No. 72-42' on file in the office of the City Clerk. RESOLUTION.,- "Air:port Traffic Control Tower MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Denny that Resolution No. 72-43 be adopted, a resolution of the City Council of the City of Redding approving lease contract between the City �of Redding /%� and the Federal Aviation Administration, covering the site of the A.irport Traffic Control Tower to be constructed on Redding Municipal Airport, to wit, lease contract no. DOT-FA72WE-1932 , including operation agreement. � Voting was as follow i: A.yes: Councilmen - Chatfield, Denny, Fulton, and Moty Noes: Councilmen - None Absent: Councilmen - Anderson , I Resolution No. 72-43 on file in the office of the City Clerk. LEA.SE - Red Cross MOTION: Made by Councilman Fulton, seconded by Councilman Chatfield approving extension of lease to the Shasta County Chapter, A.merican Red ��`� C ros s for property located at 844 Pa,r•.k-view Avenue, for an additional period of one year, to terminate on May 31 , 1973. The Vote: Unanimous A.yes EXTENSION AGREEIVIENT - Michie City Publications Co. MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Fulton approving the extension agreement Michie City Publications Co, of �� y Los Angeles and the City of Redding through June 1 , 1973 and authorizing the Mayor to sign said document on behalf of the City of Redding. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes � THE CENTER I �j �-� Councilman Fulton reopened discussion about the Teen Center. Council � concurred that a definite reply should be given to the group by June. Further discussions will take place at the Budget Sessions . PARKS DIRECTOR - Tom Riley � ��� Mayor Moty congratulated Tom Riley on his appointment as Parks Director for the City of Redding. I � 79 BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR PARK USE - Political Campaign 'IVIr., Jere E. Hurley, Jr. , Chairman of the McGovern for President campaign in Shasta County, requested the use of the west portion of ���� Lake Redding Park near the barbecue pits for a political reception on Friday, May 19th, 1972. Activities preceeding a speech by Senator McGovern would include the non-profit sale of draft beer and soft drinks . Mayor Moty declared this an urgency item. MOTION: Made by Councilman Chatfield, seconded by Councilman Denny granting permission to the McGovern for President Committee to sell beer in the Park on May 19th, 1972. The Vote: Unanimous Ayes COMPLAINT - Purley Harrison ,/, .' In a communication dated May 15, 1972, Mrs , Purley Harrison, owner �f��/ of the ABC Grocery and Burger Shop complained about conditions at the Coleman Grocery. COMPLAINT - Southern Pacific Co. Councilman Chatfield reported that he has received several complaints from citizens re the amount of smoke that is released into the air by Southern Pacific diesel engines as they idle in Redding. He requested �� � staff to review the complaint with the Health Department to determine if there is a violation of the air pollution control laws . Mayor Moty commented that the Southern Pacific switching operations are still causing serious traffic problems . Staff will check into this matter also. ROUTINE COMMUNICATIONS Communication to Planning Commission re sale of Cypress c�U� Avenue property (Mrs. Mary H. Oliver) Communication to Planning Commission re sale of Cypress ��� A.venue property (Mrs. Henry J. Huber) Building Activity Report - Month of A.pril, 1972 � �� Applications for A.lcoholic Beverage Licenses Bismarck & Bonnie L. King, dba Ricardo's l �� Timberlanes of Redding, Inc . , dba Country Bowl Gary and Jan Birkland, dba Public Market A.DJOURNMENT There being no further business , at the hour of 9:50 P. M. , on the motion of Councilman Denny, seconded by Councilman Fulton, the meeting was adj ourned.. OVED: � , M y r A.TTEST: �/�/./6:/��'a°�� �X �?.�� �z� Ci—y-Clerk � BY �'��/f.i./'C� �r°=� "t_'�l�--�, Deputy �